FROM AMAZON: The story of the British Army’s defeat at Isandlwana in 1879 has been much written about, but never with the detail and insight revealed by the research of Dr. Adrian Greaves. In reconstructing the dramatic and fateful events, Greaves draws on newly discovered letters, diaries and papers of survivors and other contemporaries. These include the contemporary writings of central figures such as Henry Harford, Lt Henry Carling of the Royal Artillery, August Hammar and young British nurse Janet Wells.
These historical documents, coupled with Greaves’s own detailed knowledge of Zululand, enable him to paint the most accurate picture yet of this cataclysmic battle that so shamed the British establishment. We learn for the first time of the complex Zulu decoy, the attempt to blame Colonel Durnford for the defeat. Greaves uncovers evidence of another “Fugitives’ Trail” escape route taken by battle survivors, as well as the identity of previously unknown escorts for Lieutenants Coghill and Melville, both awarded Victoria Crosses for trying to save the Colors.
Isandlwana: How the Zulus Humbled the British Empire by Adrian Greaves – A Book Review
“Isandlwana: How the Zulus Humbled the British Empire” by Adrian Greaves is a meticulously researched and engaging account of a pivotal battle that not only shaped the course of history but also challenged the perceived invincibility of the British Empire. In this comprehensive exploration of the Battle of Isandlwana, Greaves masterfully reconstructs the events leading up to the conflict, the battle itself, and its far-reaching consequences. The book is a testament to the author’s dedication to historical accuracy and his ability to bring this dramatic episode to life.
The narrative begins by setting the stage, introducing readers to the complex historical and political context of the late 19th century. As European powers vied for control and dominance, the British Empire found itself engaged in a turbulent and often brutal colonial expansion. Greaves provides valuable insights into the mindset of the British high command and the motivations behind their military campaigns in southern Africa. This context is crucial for understanding the events that would transpire at Isandlwana.
The Battle of Isandlwana, fought on January 22, 1879, was a clash between British forces and the Zulu warriors of King Cetshwayo. Greaves paints a vivid picture of the battlefield, the strategies employed by both sides, and the individuals involved. The book delves into the personalities of key figures, including Lord Chelmsford, the British commander, and the Zulu leaders, providing a deeper understanding of the human elements at play.
One of the book’s standout features is Greaves’ meticulous research. He draws upon a wealth of primary sources, including letters, diaries, official reports, and interviews with descendants of those who participated in the battle. This meticulous attention to detail ensures that “Isandlwana” is not just a historical account but a rich tapestry of individual stories and experiences, making the events and their consequences all the more relatable to the reader.
Greaves’ narrative style is both informative and engaging. He presents complex military strategies and tactics in an accessible manner, allowing readers with varying levels of military history knowledge to follow the story. The battle scenes are vividly described, providing a sense of the chaos, fear, and courage that defined the battlefield.
The book’s title alludes to the central question: How did the Zulus humble the British Empire? Greaves answers this question by dissecting the key factors that led to the Zulu victory. He explores the critical errors made by the British, including their underestimation of Zulu military capabilities and their overextension of their supply lines. Greaves also highlights the Zulu strengths, such as their well-trained warriors, effective tactics, and leadership.
As the narrative progresses, the sense of impending doom looms over the British forces, and Greaves masterfully conveys the mounting tension. The battle itself is a gripping and heart-wrenching account of courage, tragedy, and sacrifice. The outcome at Isandlwana marked a significant turning point in the Anglo-Zulu War and had far-reaching consequences for the British Empire’s colonial endeavors.
“Isandlwana: How the Zulus Humbled the British Empire” by Adrian Greaves is not just a military history book but a compelling exploration of the human dimensions of war. It highlights the complexity of historical events and their profound impact on the world. Greaves’ dedication to historical accuracy, his vivid storytelling, and his ability to capture the essence of the time make this book a must-read for anyone interested in military history, colonialism, and the enduring lessons of Isandlwana.
My Goodreads Review:
Isandlwana: How the Zulus Humbled the British Empire by Adrian GreavesMy rating: 4 of 5 stars
This was a military disaster for the British. They had officers who had experience fighting wars in Africa but yet their general did not listen to them.
View all my reviews
